It delivers a second-chance romance filled with heart, humor, and just the right amount of angst. John Logan, the charismatic hockey star, seems to have it all—popularity, good looks, and an endless line of girls willing to fall at his feet. But beneath his easygoing charm is a guy struggling with a future he doesn’t want. Enter Grace Ivers, a witty, slightly awkward freshman who unexpectedly catches his attention. Their first encounter is filled with chemistry, but when Logan pushes her away for reasons he barely understands himself, Grace walks—no, runs—right out of his life. And she’s not the kind of girl who waits around for a guy to figure out his feelings.
Grace’s growth throughout the book is one of its strongest aspects. When she returns to Briar University for her sophomore year, she’s more confident, more self-assured, and absolutely not interested in being Logan’s second choice. And Logan? He’s determined to win her back, but this time, he has to put in the effort. No charm, no easy passes—just pure, honest work to prove he deserves a second shot. Their dynamic is fun, flirty, and full of crackling tension, but there’s also a deeper emotional pull as both characters confront their insecurities and fears. Kennedy does a fantastic job of making their journey feel real, showing that relationships take more than just chemistry—they take trust, communication, and growth.
At its core, The Mistake is more than just a college romance; it’s a story about redemption, self-worth, and taking control of your own future. Logan’s transformation from a lost boy to a man ready to fight for what he wants is satisfying, and Grace’s refusal to settle makes her a heroine worth rooting for. The banter is sharp, the steam is high, and the emotions hit just right, making this book a perfect mix of lighthearted fun and heartfelt depth. If you love a good second-chance romance with a lovable reformed player, The Mistake is one you won’t want to miss.
Leave a comment